Home / Articles / Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries

Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries

Evgenii Vsevolodovich Beletskii 1, 
Evgenii Vsevolodovich Beletskii
Elena Valerievna Alekseeva 1, 
Elena Valerievna Alekseeva
Oleg Vladislavovich Levin 1
Oleg Vladislavovich Levin
1 St. Petersburg State University, Institute of Chemistry
Published 30 November 2021
18
Cite this
GOST
 | 
Cite this
GOST
Beletskii E. V., Alekseeva E. V., Levin O. V. Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries // Russian Chemical Reviews. 2021. Vol. 91. No. 3. RCR5030
GOST all authors (up to 50)
Beletskii E. V., Alekseeva E. V., Levin O. V. Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries // Russian Chemical Reviews. 2021. Vol. 91. No. 3. RCR5030
RIS
 | 
Cite this
RIS
TY - JOUR
DO - 10.1070/RCR5030
UR - https://rcr.colab.ws/publications/10.1070/RCR5030
TI - Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries
T2 - Russian Chemical Reviews
AU - Beletskii, Evgenii Vsevolodovich
AU - Alekseeva, Elena Valerievna
AU - Levin, Oleg Vladislavovich
PY - 2021
DA - 2021/11/30
PB - ANO Editorial Board of the journal Uspekhi Khimii
SP - RCR5030
IS - 3
VL - 91
ER -
BibTex
 | 
Cite this
BibTex (up to 50 authors)
@article{2021_Beletskii,
author = {Evgenii Vsevolodovich Beletskii and Elena Valerievna Alekseeva and Oleg Vladislavovich Levin},
title = {Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries},
journal = {Russian Chemical Reviews},
year = {2021},
volume = {91},
publisher = {ANO Editorial Board of the journal Uspekhi Khimii},
month = {Nov},
url = {https://rcr.colab.ws/publications/10.1070/RCR5030},
number = {3},
doi = {10.1070/RCR5030}
}
MLA
Cite this
MLA
Beletskii, Evgenii Vsevolodovich, et al. “Variable-resistance materials for lithium-ion batteries.” Russian Chemical Reviews, vol. 91, no. 3, Nov. 2021, p. RCR5030. https://rcr.colab.ws/publications/10.1070/RCR5030.
Views / Downloads
34 / 22

Abstract

The review focuses on variable-conductivity materials used to protect lithium-ion batteries from ignition. Examples of emergency situations arising in the operation of such batteries are given and their causes are considered. Thermal runaway that results in ignition of a lithium-ion battery and the chemical reactions accompanying this process are discussed. Internal battery protection using variable-resistance temperature- or voltage-sensitive components is described. Various approaches to the prevention of thermal runaway by modifying a battery with thermo- and voltage-resistive materials are summarized and analyzed. The advantages and drawbacks of various types of materials of this kind are demonstrated. Particular attention is paid to the practical significance of the creation and application of protective variable-resistance materials and approaches to the design of this kind of materials.

The bibliography includes 165 references.

Keywords

conductive polymers
lithium-ion batteries
overcharge
overdischarge
safety
thermoresistive properties
voltage-resistive properties

Funders

Russian Foundation for Basic Research
20-13-50195

References

1.
Synthesis, microstructure, and electrochemical performance of Li-rich layered oxide cathode materials for Li-ion batteries
Makhonina Е.V., Pechen L.S., Volkov V.V., Rumyantsev А.М., Koshtyal Y.М., Dmitrienko А.О., Politov Y.А., Pervov V.S., Eremenko I.L.
Russian Chemical Bulletin , 2019
2.
Influence of the composition on the electrochemical properties of cathode materials x Li 2 MnO 3 •(1–x)LiMn 1/3 Ni 1/3 Co 1/3 O 2 for lithium-ion batteries
Pechen L.S., Makhonina E.V., Rumyantsev A.M., Koshtyal Y.M., Volkov V.V., Goloveshkin A.S., Pervov V.S., Eremenko I.L.
Russian Chemical Bulletin , 2019
3.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib3
4.
A review on the key issues for lithium-ion battery management in electric vehicles
Lu L., Han X., Li J., Hua J., Ouyang M.
Journal of Power Sources , 2013
5.
On the use of vinylene carbonate (VC) as an additive to electrolyte solutions for Li-ion batteries
Aurbach D., Gamolsky K., Markovsky B., Gofer Y., Schmidt M., Heider U.
Electrochimica Acta , 2002
6.
Butyrolactone derivatives as electrolyte additives for lithium-ion batteries with graphite anodes
Matsuo Y., Fumita K., Fukutsuka T., Sugie Y., Koyama H., Inoue K.
Journal of Power Sources , 2003
7.
Inorganic electrolyte additives to suppress the degradation of graphite anodes by dissolved Mn(II) for lithium-ion batteries
Komaba S., Kaplan B., Ohtsuka T., Kataoka Y., Kumagai N., Groult H.
Journal of Power Sources , 2003
8.
n‐Butylferrocene for Overcharge Protection of Secondary Lithium Batteries
Abraham K.M., Pasquariello D.M., Willstaedt E.B.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 1990
9.
Status of the development of rechargeable lithium cells
Halpert G., Surampudi S., Shen D., Huang C.-., Narayanan S., Vamos E., Perrone D.
Journal of Power Sources , 1994
10.
Triphenylamines as a Class of Redox Shuttle Molecules for the Overcharge Protection of Lithium-Ion Cells
Moshurchak L.M., Buhrmester C., Dahn J.R.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2007
11.
High-Potential Redox Shuttle for Use in Lithium-Ion Batteries
Moshurchak L.M., Lamanna W.M., Bulinski M., Wang R.L., Garsuch R.R., Jiang J., Magnuson D., Triemert M., Dahn J.R.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2009
14.
Comparative study of trimethyl phosphite and trimethyl phosphate as electrolyte additives in lithium ion batteries
Yao X.L., Xie S., Chen C.H., Wang Q.S., Sun J.H., Li Y.L., Lu S.X.
Journal of Power Sources , 2005
15.
Dimethyl methylphosphonate-based nonflammable electrolyte and high safety lithium-ion batteries
Xiang H.F., Jin Q.Y., Chen C.H., Ge X.W., Guo S., Sun J.H.
Journal of Power Sources , 2007
16.
Flame-retardant additives for lithium-ion batteries
Hyung Y.E., Vissers D.R., Amine K.
Journal of Power Sources , 2003
17.
Safety Assessment of Ionic Liquid-Based Lithium-Ion Battery Prototypes
Kalhoff J., Kim G.-., Passerini S., Appetecchi G.B.
Journal of Power and Energy Engineering , 2016
18.
Nonflammable perfluoropolyether-based electrolytes for lithium batteries
Wong D.H., Thelen J.L., Fu Y., Devaux D., Pandya A.A., Battaglia V.S., Balsara N.P., DeSimone J.M.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 2014
19.
Lithium Ionic Conductor Thio-LISICON: The Li[sub 2]S-GeS[sub 2]-P[sub 2]S[sub 5] System
Kanno R., Murayama M.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2002
20.
High ionic conductivity in lithium lanthanum titanate
Inaguma Y., Liquan C., Itoh M., Nakamura T., Uchida T., Ikuta H., Wakihara M.
Solid State Communications , 1993
21.
Garnet-type solid-state fast Li ion conductors for Li batteries: critical review
Thangadurai V., Narayanan S., Pinzaru D.
Chemical Society Reviews , 2014
22.
Ionic conductivity in Li3N single crystals
Alpen U.V., Rabenau A., Talat G.H.
Applied Physics Letters , 1977
23.
Synthesis and Ionic Conductivity of Lithium-conducting Titanium Phosphate Solid Electrolytes
Kunshina G.B., Gromov O.G., Kuz'min A.P., Seitenova E.B., Lokshin E.P., Kalinnikov V.T.
Russian Journal of Applied Chemistry , 2004
24.
Nanocomposite polymer electrolytes for lithium batteries
Croce F., Appetecchi G.B., Persi L., Scrosati B.
Nature , 1998
25.
Battery Separators
Arora P., Zhang Z.(.
Chemical Reviews , 2004
29.
Thermal runaway caused fire and explosion of lithium ion battery
Wang Q., Ping P., Zhao X., Chu G., Sun J., Chen C.
Journal of Power Sources , 2012
30.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib30
31.
A review of lithium ion battery failure mechanisms and fire prevention strategies
Wang Q., Mao B., Stoliarov S.I., Sun J.
Progress in Energy and Combustion Science , 2019
32.
Investigating the thermal runaway mechanisms of lithium-ion batteries based on thermal analysis database
Feng X., Zheng S., Ren D., He X., Wang L., Cui H., Liu X., Jin C., Zhang F., Xu C., Hsu H., Gao S., Chen T., Li Y., Wang T., et. al.
Applied Energy , 2019
33.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib33
Zhang
Acta Phys. — Chim. Sinica , 2021
35.
Temperature characteristics of lithium iron phosphatepower batteries under overcharge
Zhang Z., Du Z., Han Z., Wang H., Wang S.
International Journal of Energy Research , 2020
36.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib36
Spiers
2017
37.
Degradation Mechanism Study and Safety Hazard Analysis of Overdischarge on Commercialized Lithium-ion Batteries.
Ma T., Wu S., Wang F., Lacap J., Lin C., Liu S., Wei M., Hao W., Wang Y., Park J.W.
ACS applied materials & interfaces , 2020
38.
Overdischarge and Aging Analytics of Li-Ion Cells
Juarez-Robles D., Vyas A.A., Fear C., Jeevarajan J.A., Mukherjee P.P.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2020
41.
Investigation of Short-Circuit Scenarios in a Lithium-Ion Battery Cell
Zavalis T.G., Behm M., Lindbergh G.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2012
42.
Materials for lithium-ion battery safety
Liu K., Liu Y., Lin D., Pei A., Cui Y.
Science advances , 2018
43.
A review of lithium-ion battery safety concerns: The issues, strategies, and testing standards
Chen Y., Kang Y., Zhao Y., Wang L., Liu J., Li Y., Liang Z., He X., Li X., Tavajohi N., Li B.
Journal of Energy Chemistry , 2021
47.
Failure mechanism of the lithium ion battery during nail penetration
Mao B., Chen H., Cui Z., Wu T., Wang Q.
International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 2018
48.
Effects of Overdischarge Rate on Thermal Runaway of NCM811 Li-Ion Batteries
Wang D., Zheng L., Li X., Du G., Zhang Z., Feng Y., Jia L., Dai Z.
Energies , 2020
49.
Experimental study on the thermal behaviors of lithium-ion batteries under discharge and overcharge conditions
Ouyang D., He Y., Chen M., Liu J., Wang J.
Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry , 2017
50.
Mitigating Thermal Runaway of Lithium-Ion Batteries
52.
Safety mechanisms in lithium-ion batteries
Balakrishnan P.G., Ramesh R., Prem Kumar T.
Journal of Power Sources , 2006
53.
Catastrophe analysis of cylindrical lithium ion battery
Wang Q., Ping P., Sun J.
Nonlinear Dynamics , 2010
54.
Thermal Model for a Li-Ion Cell
Kumaresan K., Sikha G., White R.E.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2007
55.
Study on the thermal interaction and heat dissipation of cylindrical Lithium-Ion Battery cells
Huang Y., Lu Y., Huang R., Chen J., Chen F., Liu Z., Yu X., Roskilly A.P.
Energy Procedia , 2017
56.
Heat dissipation design for lithium-ion batteries
Wu M., Liu K.H., Wang Y., Wan C.
Journal of Power Sources , 2002
57.
Thermal runaway mechanism of lithium ion battery for electric vehicles: A review
Feng X., Ouyang M., Liu X., Lu L., Xia Y., He X.
Energy Storage Materials , 2018
59.
A review of safety strategies of a Li-ion battery
Chombo P.V., Laoonual Y.
Journal of Power Sources , 2020
60.
Thermal runaway behavior during overcharge for large-format Lithium-ion batteries with different packaging patterns
Huang L., Zhang Z., Wang Z., Zhang L., Zhu X., Dorrell D.D.
Journal of Energy Storage , 2019
61.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib61
Guo
2018
62.
Abuse behavior of high-power, lithium-ion cells
Spotnitz R., Franklin J.
Journal of Power Sources , 2003
63.
Probing of Internal Short Circuit in Lithium-Ion Pouch Cells by Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy under Mechanical Abusive Conditions
Thangavel N.K., Mundhe S., Islam M.M., Newaz G., Arava L.M.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2020
64.
Three-dimensional thermal finite element modeling of lithium-ion battery in thermal abuse application
65.
A three-dimensional thermal abuse model for lithium-ion cells
Kim G., Pesaran A., Spotnitz R.
Journal of Power Sources , 2007
66.
Recent advances of thermal safety of lithium ion battery for energy storage
Lyu P., Liu X., Qu J., Zhao J., Huo Y., Qu Z., Rao Z.
Energy Storage Materials , 2020
68.
Comparing Different Thermal Runaway Triggers for Two Automotive Lithium-Ion Battery Cell Types
Essl C., Golubkov A.W., Fuchs A.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2020
69.
Recent advances in the mitigation of dendrites in lithium-metal batteries
Hundekar P., Jain R., Lakhnot A.S., Koratkar N.
Journal of Applied Physics , 2020
70.
Effects of lithium dendrites on thermal runaway and gassing of LiFePO4 batteries
Wang S., Rafiz K., Liu J., Jin Y., Lin J.Y.
Sustainable Energy and Fuels , 2020
71.
Lithium metal batteries for high energy density: Fundamental electrochemistry and challenges
Gao M., Li H., Xu L., Xue Q., Wang X., Bai Y., Wu C.
Journal of Energy Chemistry , 2021
73.
In Situ Solid State 7Li NMR Observations of Lithium Metal Deposition during Overcharge in Lithium Ion Batteries
Arai J., Okada Y., Sugiyama T., Izuka M., Gotoh K., Takeda K.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2015
75.
Thermal behaviour of the lithiated-graphite/electrolyte interface through GC/MS analysis
Gachot G., Grugeon S., Eshetu G.G., Mathiron D., Ribière P., Armand M., Laruelle S.
Electrochimica Acta , 2012
78.
Initiation of thermal runaway in Lithium-ion cells by inductive heating
Kriston A., Kersys A., Antonelli A., Ripplinger S., Holmstrom S., Trischler S., Döring H., Pfrang A.
Journal of Power Sources , 2020
79.
A polyethylene microsphere-coated separator with rapid thermal shutdown function for lithium-ion batteries
Zhang C., Li H., Wang S., Cao Y., Yang H., Ai X., Zhong F.
Journal of Energy Chemistry , 2020
80.
Effects of separator breakdown on abuse response of 18650 Li-ion cells
Roth E.P., Doughty D.H., Pile D.L.
Journal of Power Sources , 2007
83.
Experimental Study on Pyrolysis Kinetics and Thermal Stability of Li (Ni1/3Co1/3Mn1/3)O2 Cathode Material at Different State of Charge
Wei Z., Cao H., Liang C., Wang Z., Feng L., Wang Q., Sun J.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2021
84.
Study on Thermal Simulation of LiNi 0.5 Mn 1.5 O 4 /Li 4 Ti 5 O 12 Battery
Yang K., Shan Z., Liu X., Tan L., Wang S.
Energy Technology , 2021
85.
Structural Changes and Thermal Stability of Charged LiNixMnyCozO2 Cathode Materials Studied by Combined In Situ Time-Resolved XRD and Mass Spectroscopy
Bak S., Hu E., Zhou Y., Yu X., Senanayake S.D., Cho S., Kim K., Chung K.Y., Yang X., Nam K.
ACS applied materials & interfaces , 2014
86.
Building Safe Lithium-Ion Batteries for Electric Vehicles: A Review
Duan J., Tang X., Dai H., Yang Y., Wu W., Wei X., Huang Y.
Electrochemical Energy Reviews , 2019
88.
How Electrolytes Influence Battery Safety.
Roth E.P., Orendorff C.J.
Electrochemical Society Interface , 2012
89.
Design Strategies of Safe Electrolytes for Preventing Thermal Runaway in Lithium Ion Batteries
Tian X., Yi Y., Fang B., Yang P., Wang T., Liu P., Qu L., Li M., Zhang S.
Chemistry of Materials , 2020
92.
Polyimide separators for rechargeable batteries
Lu Z., Sui F., Miao Y., Liu G., Li C., Dong W., Cui J., Liu T., Wu J., Yang C.
Journal of Energy Chemistry , 2021
97.
Self‐Protection of Electrochemical Storage Devices via a Thermal Reversible Sol–Gel Transition
Yang H., Liu Z., Chandran B.K., Deng J., Yu J., Qi D., Li W., Tang Y., Zhang C., Chen X.
Advanced Materials , 2015
98.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib100
Zheng
Chemistry Select , 2018
99.
Cathode material comparison of thermal runaway behavior of Li-ion cells at different state of charges including over charge
Mendoza-Hernandez O.S., Ishikawa H., Nishikawa Y., Maruyama Y., Umeda M.
Journal of Power Sources , 2015
100.
Building a Thermal Shutdown Cathode for Li‐Ion Batteries Using Temperature‐Responsive Poly(3‐Dodecylthiophene)
101.
Building thermally stable Li-ion batteries using a temperature-responsive cathode
Ji W., Wang F., Liu D., Qian J., Cao Y., Chen Z., Yang H., Ai X.
Journal of Materials Chemistry A , 2016
102.
Temperature-sensitive cathode materials for safer lithium-ion batteries
Xia L., Li S., Ai X., Yang H., Cao Y.
Energy and Environmental Science , 2011
103.
Switchable resistance conducting-polymer layer for Li-ion battery overcharge protection
Beletskii E.V., Fedorova A.A., Lukyanov D.A., Kalnin A.Y., Ershov V.A., Danilov S.E., Spiridonova D.V., Alekseeva E.V., Levin O.V.
Journal of Power Sources , 2021
104.
Facile and Effective Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC) Layer for Safer Lithium-Ion Batteries
Jin H., Han X., Radjenovic P.M., Tian J., Li J.
Journal of Physical Chemistry C , 2021
106.
Fast and reversible thermoresponsive polymer switching materials for safer batteries
Chen Z., Hsu P., Lopez J., Li Y., To J.W., Liu N., Wang C., Andrews S., Liu J., Cui Y., Bao Z.
Nature Energy , 2016
112.
rcr_91_3_RCR5030bib114
Xu
2016
114.
Resistivity-Temperature Behavior of Intrinsically Conducting Bis(3-methoxysalicylideniminato)nickel Polymer
Beletskii E., Ershov V., Danilov S., Lukyanov D., Alekseeva E., Levin O.
Polymers , 2020
116.
Doping and dedoping processes in poly (3-alkylthiophenes)
Loponen M.T., Taka T., Laakso J., Väkiparta K., Suuronen K., Valkeinen P., Österholm J.-.
Synthetic Metals , 1991
117.
The routes towards processible and stable conducting poly(thiophene)s
Pei Q., Inganäs O., Gustafsson G., Granström M., Andersson M., Hjertberg T., Wennerström O., Österholm J.E., Laakso J., Järvinen H.
Synthetic Metals , 1993
119.
Mechanism of dedoping processes of conducting poly(3-alkylthiophenes).
Koizumi H., Dougauchi H., Ichikawa T.
Journal of Physical Chemistry B , 2005
121.
Kim J.H., Cho H., Kim S.H., Kim J.Y.
Macromolecular Research , 2004
123.
Safe positive temperature coefficient composite cathode for lithium ion battery
Zhong H., Kong C., Zhan H., Zhan C., Zhou Y.
Journal of Power Sources , 2012
125.
A Positive-Temperature-Coefficient Layer Based on Ni-Mixed Poly (Vinylidene Fluoride) Composites for LiFePO4 Electrode
Li J., Chen J., Lu H., Jia M., Jiang L., Lai Y., Zhang Z.
International Journal of Electrochemical Science , 2013
126.
Accelerated degradation model for C-rate loading of lithium-ion batteries
Saxena S., Xing Y., Kwon D., Pecht M.
International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems , 2019
128.
Unusual positive temperature coefficient effect of polyolefin/carbon fiber conductive composites
129.
Alternating Current Impedance Behavior and Overcharge Tolerance of Lithium-Ion Batteries Using Positive Temperature Coefficient Cathodes
Kise M., Yoshioka S., Hamano K., Kuriki H., Nishimura T., Urushibata H.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2007
130.
Development of new safe electrode for lithium rechargeable battery
Kise M., Yoshioka S., Hamano K., Takemura D., Nishimura T., Urushibata H., Yoshiyasu H.
Journal of Power Sources , 2005
131.
Effect of the Addition of Conductive Material to Positive Temperature Coefficient Cathodes of Lithium-Ion Batteries
Kise M., Yoshioka S., Hamano K., Kuriki H., Nishimura T., Urushibata H., Yoshiyasu H.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2005
133.
Autonomic Shutdown of Lithium‐Ion Batteries Using Thermoresponsive Microspheres
Baginska M., Blaiszik B.J., Merriman R.J., Sottos N.R., Moore J.S., White S.R.
Advanced Energy Materials , 2012
136.
The Effect of Electrode Potential on the Conductivity of Polymer Complexes of Nickel with Salen Ligands
Beletskii E.V., Volosatova Y.A., Eliseeva S.N., Levin O.V.
Russian Journal of Electrochemistry , 2019
137.
Quantifying TEMPO Redox Polymer Charge Transport toward the Organic Radical Battery
Karlsson C., Suga T., Nishide H.
ACS applied materials & interfaces , 2017
138.
Electrochemistry of Conducting Polymers—Persistent Models and New Concepts
Heinze J., Frontana-Uribe B.A., Ludwigs S.
Chemical Reviews , 2010
139.
A composite polymer membrane with reversible overcharge protection mechanism for lithium ion batteries
Xiao L.F., Ai X.P., Cao Y.L., Wang Y.D., Yang H.X.
Electrochemistry Communications , 2005
142.
Modeling the Behavior of Electroactive Polymers for Overcharge Protection of Lithium Batteries
Thomas-Alyea K.E., Newman J., Chen G., Richardson T.J.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2004
143.
Overcharge Protection for Rechargeable Lithium Batteries Using Electroactive Polymers
Chen G., Richardson T.J.
Electrochemical and Solid-State Letters , 2004
144.
Overcharge Protection for 4 V Lithium Batteries at High Rates and Low Temperatures
Chen G., Richardson T.J.
Journal of the Electrochemical Society , 2010
145.
Stable and high-rate overcharge protection for rechargeable lithium batteries
Wang B., Richardson T.J., Chen G.
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics , 2013
148.
Overcharge Protection for High Voltage Lithium Cells Using Two Electroactive Polymers
Chen G., Richardson T.J.
Electrochemical and Solid-State Letters , 2006
150.
A redox-active polythiophene-modified separator for safety control of lithium-ion batteries
Zhang H., Cao Y., Yang H., Lu S., Ai X.
Journal of Polymer Science, Part B: Polymer Physics , 2013
151.
Advanced poly(vinyl alcohol) porous separator with overcharge protection function for lithium-ion batteries
155.
Modeling of the overcharge behavior of lithium-ion battery cells protected by a voltage-switchable resistive polymer layer
Fedorova A.A., Anishchenko D.V., Beletskii E.V., Kalnin A.Y., Levin O.V.
Journal of Power Sources , 2021
158.
Conducting polymers containing in-chain metal centers: Homogeneous charge transport through a quaterthienyl-bridged {Os(tpy)2} polymer
Hjelm J., Handel R.W., Hagfeldt A., Constable E.C., Housecroft C.E., Forster R.J.
Journal of Physical Chemistry B , 2003
160.
Conducting metallopolymers based on azaferrocene.
Byrne P.D., Müller P., Swager T.M.
Langmuir , 2006